Insights/Tax Planning
Tax Planning

Reasonable Compensation: Setting a Defensible Salary for S Corporation Owners

Owner salary is the hinge of every S corporation. Set it too low and it invites scrutiny; set it too high and the election loses its purpose.

Every S corporation shareholder who performs services for the business must be paid reasonable compensation before receiving distributions. The requirement is simple to state and harder to apply, because the tax code does not define a number. It asks what the business would have to pay someone else to do the work the owner does.

Why it matters

Salary is subject to payroll taxes. Distributions are not. That difference creates an incentive to keep salary low, and it is why owner compensation is a recurring focus of IRS examinations of S corporations. When salary is unreasonably low, distributions can be recharacterized as wages, with payroll tax, penalties and interest assessed.

The factors that support a salary

  • The owner's duties and responsibilities, and the time devoted to the business.
  • Training and experience.
  • What comparable businesses pay for similar services.
  • Compensation agreements and the use of a formula for bonuses.
  • The business's gross receipts, profit and distribution history.
  • The portion of revenue generated by the owner's personal services compared with capital, equipment and employees.

For a single-owner professional practice where nearly all revenue comes from the owner's work, a larger share of profit will usually be supportable as salary. For a contracting company with crews, equipment and project managers, more of the profit may be attributable to the business itself.

Documentation

The strongest position is a written analysis prepared before or during the year, showing the owner's roles, the market data considered and the reasoning for the salary chosen. A number chosen after the fact, without support, is difficult to defend.

Interaction with the rest of the plan

Owner salary also affects retirement plan contributions, which are often calculated on W-2 wages, and the qualified business income deduction, which is limited in part by wages paid. Setting compensation is therefore a planning decision, not only a compliance one, and it should be revisited each year.

A note on mid-year changes

Salary should be paid through regular payroll during the year. A single year end payroll entry is weaker evidence of a genuine compensation arrangement and creates its own deposit and penalty issues.

This article is general information, not tax, legal or accounting advice for your situation. Tax rules change and their application depends on your facts. Speak with an advisor before acting.

Begin the conversation

Schedule a consultation with Integers.

The first consultation is complimentary for every service except individual tax returns. Meetings are held by video or phone, Monday to Friday, 9 am to 5 pm in your time zone.

Schedule a Consultation →

Or call (800) 777-5277. We reply within one business day.

Filing an individual return? Start Your Return